View Full Version : Diffuser doubt
dsn24
10-13-2011, 07:53 PM
we know that fluid flows from higher pressure to lower pressure then how is the flow taking place from the inlet of the diffuser to the exit of the diffuser when the pressure is actually increasing from the inlet to the outlet??
im a bit confused abt this!!
dsn24
10-13-2011, 07:53 PM
we know that fluid flows from higher pressure to lower pressure then how is the flow taking place from the inlet of the diffuser to the exit of the diffuser when the pressure is actually increasing from the inlet to the outlet??
im a bit confused abt this!!
Google bernoulli's eqn.
If you are a real person. If you are a fake person, go back to being fake.
Edit:
Question for everyone now that I think about it. Why do people have the need to register a fake account then smear our forums with this nonsense?
I make the following assumptions:
1. There is no way anyone but an SAE student/alumn knows about this forum (perhaps baja)
2. Therefore these people are either FSAE/baja students or alumn
3. If you are an alumn I understand staying on the forums but only for the purpose of talking about racecars because you are nostalgic
4. If you are a student, why are you not building your race car or trying to elicit good conversation? I know we are not the most mature folk but this is grade school kind of stuff. FSAE students are into high brow racecar humor, not slapstick 6th grade antics.
There is only one possible answer. Its a middle-school Baja team.
dsn24
10-13-2011, 09:26 PM
you are misunderstanding me. all i want to know is how a diffuser is able to perform the pumping action when the pressure is lower at the inlet and higher at the exit.
there's nothing wrong in clarifying doubts i suppose.
theTTshark
10-13-2011, 09:36 PM
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by ZAMR:
Google bernoulli's eqn.
If you are a real person. If you are a fake person, go back to being fake.
Edit:
Question for everyone now that I think about it. Why do people have the need to register a fake account then smear our forums with this nonsense?
I make the following assumptions:
1. There is no way anyone but an SAE student/alumn knows about this forum (perhaps baja)
2. Therefore these people are either FSAE/baja students or alumn
3. If you are an alumn I understand staying on the forums but only for the purpose of talking about racecars because you are nostalgic
4. If you are a student, why are you not building your race car or trying to elicit good conversation? I know we are not the most mature folk but this is grade school kind of stuff. FSAE students are into high brow racecar humor, not slapstick 6th grade antics.
There is only one possible answer. Its a middle-school Baja team. </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
Where did this come from? This is a legitimate question.
CameronBeaton
10-14-2011, 12:49 AM
There is actually a pressure loss in the system, meaning the pressure at the inlet is higher that the exit. (my understanding is it goes high-low-high)
manifold
10-14-2011, 02:00 AM
It appears that there's more thrashing around people than actually helping others understand/find solutions in this forum. Such is the atmosphere here, Im expecting another 1000 accounts with 1 post each in it.
Until the members here understand that "Knowledge shared is knowledge gained" this forum will just be a marketing gimic.
If any moderator is watching, a good suggestion would be to update the forum rules to ban this nonsense.
Edit:
Every time i come here thinking i can learn something i see crappy posts like these. The older posts here actually have some stuff in them.
Listen I apologize to dsn24 if this is a legitimate question, but it is hard to believe this is at all honest.
dsn24 has only 1 post, posted on October 13, and he registered Oct 13. The question is in my opinion not one to ask on the forums especially since there should (hopefully) be more knowledgeable people on his team that can answer it.
On the same day (Oct 13) bishoY registered and posted:
I`d like to ask .. what r the materials of double wishbone ? and the specifications for each ?
thanks
he was, characteristically, chided.
October 13 was quite a day for first time forum users and coincidentally some questions with questionable origins. Based on this forum's history of trolls and the coincidences listed above, I am a skeptic.
Forums are typically for discussing problems or ideas that don't have clearly defined answers. This is why everyone begs new users to use the search function. Instead we have a dumbing-down of the forums, which we are all guilty of (myself included).
Sorry to everyone, it just peeves me a little.
Jan_Dressler
10-14-2011, 12:12 PM
It is indeed a legitimate question, and a very interesting and sometimes controversial one... Bernoulli might not always be enough. http://fsae.com/groupee_common/emoticons/icon_wink.gif
But the thread opener might have looked up "Diffuser (automotive)" in Wikipedia, then read the article about "Lift (force)", and then maybe some research in forums like f1technical before asking that question here...
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by CameronBeaton:
There is actually a pressure loss in the system, meaning the pressure at the inlet is higher that the exit. (my understanding is it goes high-low-high) </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
This is true because with any viscid and real gas there is irrecoverable pressure loss. Other than restricting mass flow, this is one effect that engine restrictors have. Reducing this pressure loss is something restrictor designers should look at, since you can change this pressure loss using different geometries.
However, this is not the reason that air flows through a diffuser under a car. That is to say a perfect inviscid gas would still flow through the diffuser without a net pressure drop in the system.
Even with a real gas, where do you define the beginning and end of your streamline? It is of course an arbitrary point. You could define the beginning of the streamline 100m in front of the car and 200m behind the car and the static pressure and velocity relative to the car would be the exact same. Similarly, you could say the car is in a closed loop windtunnel, i.e. a volume of gas can take a complete revolution and arrive at the same place with the same pressure and velocity. So why does the air flow at all?
Of course you would say "duh because the car is moving" or the air is moving. There's the answer right there.
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">
Originally posted by Jan_Dressler:
It is indeed a legitimate question, and a very interesting and sometimes controversial one... Bernoulli might not always be enough.
But the thread opener might have looked up "Diffuser (automotive)" in Wikipedia, then read the article about "Lift (force)", and then maybe some research in forums like f1technical before asking that question here... </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
The answer is not controversial, in fact it is as basic as physics gets, and Bernoulli's equation is more than enough. You need to understand Bernoulli's equation and be able to break it down into its conceptual components. That entails some basic knowledge of high school physics, mainly the relationship between velocity, acceleration, and position.
If an object is moving at velocity v, it will continue moving at velocity v unless acted on by another force.
Pressure can be defined as force/area. Let's say pressure P exerts a force F on an object of mass m moving at velocity v. And lets say the pressure changes with distance traveled. If pressure changes as a function of distance (ie a pressure gradient), and let's say it varies linearly, then velocity of the object will change with a v^2 relationship (you can do the calculus). Herein lies the connection with Bernoulli's equation. The object we are talking about is a volume of gas, and the pressure gradient is, well the pressure gradient along the streamline.
See the reason the gas travels through the diffuser at an adverse pressure gradient is because it has velocity wrt the car. Just as any object can continue moving in the same direction with a force applied in the opposite direction, so can air. The air starts at static atmospheric pressure and velocity equal in magnitude to the car's velocity, then as it must pass through a smaller area, the pressure drops/velocity increases (pressure gradient is such that it speeds up the air) then the air emerges from the diffuser. The pressure gradient from the throat to the exit is an adverse one, and the pressure slows down the air (the adverse pressure gradient does not mean the air must flow backwards, it just means the air slows down because the gas pressure exerts a force opposite to the direction of travel).
Not controversial, Newtonian physics. Perhaps interesting, but there are bigger fish to fry. Still, understanding the basic physics is important if you want to design a good diffuser. Understanding allows you to break free from copying. Most diffusers I see have poorly designed entrances for FSAE, basically because they copy F1 or some other racing series which has restrictions on diffuser rules. When net downforce and high cl's are important (as in FSAE), you can modify the nozzle design to help achieve that goal.
@manifold:
There are still a few posts on the forums that are interesting. Take the recent tilt table post for instance, I think everyone can learn something from that. I find it very interesting. All forums have nonsense in them, you just have to sort through it I guess...
dsn24
10-16-2011, 10:52 PM
thanks so much for your explanation ZMR.
it cleared most of the confusion!!!
Jan_Dressler
10-17-2011, 11:49 AM
@ZAMR:
I absolutely agree with your post, nice explanations (and I think I am able to understand Bernoulli http://fsae.com/groupee_common/emoticons/icon_wink.gif).
But I like to throw some words into the discussion here:
- Boundary layer <--> Bernoulli
- Vortex-based aerodynamics / wings with very low A/R (undertray) http://fsae.com/groupee_common/emoticons/icon_smile.gif
CameronBeaton
10-19-2011, 12:58 AM
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by ZAMR:
Of course you would say "duh because the car is moving" or the air is moving. There's the answer right there.
</div></BLOCKQUOTE>
Haha thanks, I was going to say that in the first place but it sound too obvious and I then over complicated it in my head
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.5 Copyright © 2025 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.