Ethical Question:
A senior on our team has decided not only to quit FSAE, but his mechanical engineering education also. He would have graduated this spring.
We are an excellent team, and maybe this year we've had the least amount of teaming problems ever. I speak as a senior and 4th year member myself. The FSAE program has been at our school for many years now.
This quitting team member was engineering lead on one of the major systems on our car. He didn't contribute much in our fall (design) semester. No solid or parametric modeling was done by him, and all analysis (Abaqus) was actually done for him by a junior member.
He did some hand calculations and determined why a part fatigued on last year's car. So he did decide to tractor factor it up. Once this first iteration was found to be strong enough using Abaqus, he made no more iterations. This was the only part he designed in a whole system.
He's been on the team about 3 years and does know how to machine parts really well (its what he does at his part time job).
He wants to machine this part that he "designed." In my book, I believe that the work you have to do for these teams is a privelege. It would be nice for someone to make parts and decrease the always heavy workload, but I can't justify this case.
Would you let this person make the part?